Man City accused of misleading Premier League over finances
Manchester City were accused by the Premier League Monday of providing misleading information about its finances over a nine-year period when the club were attempting to establish themselves as a force in English and European football following their takeover by Abu Dhabi’s ruling family.
The explosive development came at the end of a four-year investigation by the world’s most popular football league in the wake of leaked club emails and documents from City officials that were published by German magazine Der Spiegel in November 2018, AP reports.
The Premier League released a long statement detailing a list of about 80 alleged breaches of its financial rules by City from 2009-18, the first nine full seasons under Abu Dhabi ownership. In that time, the team won three Premier League titles – in 2012, 2014 and 2018 – in what has become the most successful period in City’s 143-year history.
The league also accused City of 30 more breaches relating to their alleged failure to cooperate with the investigation since December 2018.
The league said it has referred the breaches to an independent commission ahead of a confidential hearing.
In a statement, City said they were “surprised” by the allegations, “particularly given the extensive engagement and vast amount of detailed materials that the EPL (English Premier League) has been provided with.
“The club welcome the review of this matter by an independent commission to impartially consider the comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence that exists in support of their position,” City said. “As such, we look forward to this matter being put to rest once and for all.”
The Premier League has accused City of breaching rules requiring provision “in utmost good faith” of “accurate financial information that gives a true and fair view of the club’s financial position” between 2009-18 and failing to give “full details of manager remuneration in their relevant contracts” from 2009-13. Roberto Mancini was the manager during that period.
The third and fourth offences are a failure to comply with UEFA regulations from 2013-18 and the Premier League’s profitability and sustainability rules from 2015-18.
For the fifth offence, City are accused of breaching rules requiring clubs to “cooperate with and assist the Premier League with its investigations” from December 2018 to the present day.
City, the defending Premier League champions and a team owning some of the world’s top players like Erling Haaland and Kevin De Bruyne, could be at risk of severe punishment. The league’s rule book gives a disciplinary commission powers to impose a range of sanctions plus the wider scope of “such other penalty as it shall think fit.”
A large fine seems inevitable if the charges are proven. Also in play is a point deduction, a title nullified or even being expelled from the league, according to league rules.
City never disputed that the documents leaked by Der Spiegel were authentic, but argued the evidence was stolen and reported out of context.
While City were under investigation by the Premier League, the club had a two-year ban from European club competitions overturned by the Court of Arbitration for Sport in 2020 after UEFA ruled City committed “serious breaches” of financial fair play regulations from 2012-16. That case arose on the back of the leaked information, too.
City were not fully cleared of wrongdoing, though the court said some of the allegations were not proven or could not be judged because of a statute of limitations in UEFA rules. There are no such time limits on the finances under investigation by the Premier League.
CAS also fined City 10 million euros (then $11.3 million) for failing to cooperate with investigators. The club’s “blatant disregard” should be “strongly condemned,” the court’s judges said.
City have been transformed into an English football power since being bought in September 2008 by Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, a deputy prime minister of the United Arab Emirates and a member of Abu Dhabi’s royal family.
Under their Abu Dhabi ownership, City – who previously lived in the shadow of neighbour Manchester United – have won six Premier League titles, two FA Cups and six English League Cups.
The team are in second place in the Premier League midway through this season, five points behind Arsenal having played one match more.